
Home | News | Social:Life | Student Life | Get Involved | Events | Forums | Shop | Directory
|
An occasional commentary on the fundamental things in life Latest diary entries by JonathanG tagged with "opt out"
By Jonathan Martin Goddard
on Wed, 23rd Jan 2008 at 16:34
I'd like to get a debate going on the subject of organ donation. Gordon Brown has approved the "opt-out" system of organ donation, replacing the current "opt-in" system, whereby people who give no express order to have their organs kept are buried with them. Personally, as a student of health sciences, I feel that this is a step in the right direction, as so many people neglect to express a wish either way and as a result, thousands or millions of people die for want of viable organs. At the moment, there are probably millions of people who have no great wish to have their organs when they're buried or cremated but who haven't expressed a wish to donate them to needy people. I've seen so many people already griping over this proposal, saying it's an erosion of their rights. Their rights to what, exactly? To rot in one piece? To go up in smoke with the lives of maybe six other people? I realise that some people may be religious and think that maybe god won't let them into heaven after giving their organs to save someone else's life, but really it smacks of vanity and greed. To these people, I ask: If it was you who needed that organ, would you condone this behaviour? If it was a member of your family that needed a new heart, would you be complaining about this "harvesting"? Having worked in a hospital, I can fully understand the dearth of organs in the NHS organ transplant system and it irks me that people think that doctors are harvesting people with their eyes and notebooks. The doctors' first job is to preserve the lives of their patients, not other people's. Giving your organs to another person after you die is the greatest gift a person can give, it's passing on your fading life to give someone a new, fuller life. I realise this almost sounds like I'm being paid to sell the idea, but I know that when I die, I want to give my organs to someone else. It's a tragedy that so many organs go to waste because of apathy and ignorance. If people are really so vehemently opposed to giving their organs, they can say so. Those who are ignorant or indifferent are hardly likely to be too offended once their brains cease to function and they die, are they? And if their families are worried, they can opt out on their behalf, or one would hope so. Hopefully, the consultation will iron things out in this respect. I'd love to hear what everyone else thinks about this situation too. Please share!
P.S. Thanks to James, AKA Orwellian Trash on LiveJournal for the inspiration for this blog. Permanent link
2 Comments
WelcomeHELP ME! PLEASE! I'M A RAVING LUNATIC!!!!1 busiest tagsapathy arrest arrested debate depression guide innocent law medical opt in opt out organ donation police protest stereotypes drinking... stress students survival unionCalendar« July 2008
about me"Biomedical scientist, front page journo"
my degreeBSc (hons) Biomedical Science blogroll & links (what's this?)This member hasn't added any links to their diary's sidebar yet. If this is your diary, you can add links (or any other HTML) in your profile's "diary settings" tab Latest entriesLatest commentsSearch this blog
Bookmarkdigg this | technorati | del.icio.us | facebook | on your computer (what's this?) Browsehome | news | events | social:life | photo galleries | student life | get involved | forums | blogs Exploresearch | UPSUuuuuugle | tags: news & webpages, blogs, members' interests Services
jobshop
|
copy shop
|
news desk & press
|
corporate
|
advertising
|
Help & infodirectory | help | privacy | conditions of use | feedback The Unionabout | contact | map & directions | opening hours | the union on facebook 852 people are currently reading UPSU.net |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
