Advertisement

Diary entries by ben_norman on Fri 18th Apr 2008

The deep chill of Thursday evening was off-set by a heated debate between local politicians from across the party spectrum in a Question time style debate in Park building, chaired by Morys Ireland and hosted by the Labour student’s society. The panel consisted of  Councillor Gerald Vernon-Jackson  a member of the Liberal Democrats and leader of Portsmouth City Council, alongside Labour MP for Portsmouth North Sarah Mc-Carthy-Fry MP, UKIP member Steve Harris, Respect candidate John Molyneux, Tim Dawes of the Green Party and Nick Chaffey Socialist Party regional coordinater and trade unionist. The topics covered included the role of local government in combatting climate change, wheather immigration is a strain or a benefit to the economy and should there have been a vote over the recent EU Lisbon treaty.  This is the first time that so many political figures have agreed to form a panel at a student meeting. The 20,000 students studying at this University make up over 10% of the local voting population, a sizable portion of the electorate, sizable enougth to win an election if it could be won over.

 

When discussing the role of local government in fighting climate change both incumerbant politicians focused discussion on initiatives taken on a local level, such as efforts to persuade Portsmouth drivers to take public transportation, at one point Counciller Vernon-Jackson alluded to plans for a tram system in Portsmouth. Steve Harris the UKIP spokesman took the contreoversial stance to deny the existance of climate change, denouncing enviromentalism as “a new religion.” Nick Chaffy, the Socialist Party spokesman questioned the privatisation polices of local services, which places climate change in the hands of the free market. John Molinuex denied that climate change could be solved in Portsmouth and called for the audience to examine the wider picture, in response Tim Dawes called for the audience and panel alike to “think globally, but act locally”, agreeing that the world scernario must be kept in mind but people can act on a personal and local level. Whilst as I member of the Socialist Party myself I may be accused of bias but I stand by my opinion that Nick Chaffy and Tim Dawes proved themselves to be the best of the speakers, through the strength and reason of their arguments as well as their oratory style, an opinion that was confirmed as the chair moved on to the second question, the impact of immigration on the economy.

 

Steve Harris of UKIP lived up to his political sterotype by denouncing immigration as a drain on the national resources, claiming that the freedom of movement inside the European Union was the main cause of the problem. Harris stated that in tower hamlets election ballot papers were printed in sixty nine languages, citing this as an absurdity of multi-cultural Britain. In strong contrast John Molinuex, whose party calls for completely open borders with no restrictions on immigration, argued that the economic arguments for and against immigration were irrelevant compared to the cultural and human values. Surely, Molinuex argued, if a school child can speak or understand 21 languages “this is a magnificent thing.”  Both Counciller Vernon-Jackson and Sarah Mcart...
About 543 more words in this entry


Welcome

Welcome to my blog.

Calendar

« April 18th, 2008

sun mon tue wed thu fri sat
12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930

about me

"Like Gollum but with a bouncy walk"

This member hasn't written anything about themselves yet.

If this is your diary, you can add a bit about yourself in your profile's "diary settings" tab

See Ben_Norman's profile.

Search this blog